It’s too bad that Dan Shaughnessy Watch is closing down. But lest we forget…I’m posting today’s final offering to remember just how dreadful a journalist the Boston Globe’s “top” sports writer really is:
The CHB outdoes himself today, flip-flopping all over the sports page like a netted cod. He criticizes the Red Sox for overspending for Daisuke Matsuzaka while also arguing that the Sox are finally waking up to the “fact” they need to “win now.” The piece epitomizes everything that is wrong with Dan Shaughnessy:
His problem with facts:
*“The Red Sox just spent $51.1 million for the right to negotiate with a player.” Wrong. The Red Sox didn’t spend anything to negotiate with him. They pay only if he signs. Try reading Nick Carfado, Dan-o.
*“One year later, the Contreras contretemps was followed by the Alex Rodriguez Valentine’s Day fiasco.” Since that “fiasco,” the Red Sox have been to the playoffs twice and won a World Series – one more than A-Rod’s Yankees.
His incoherent babble:
*He complains about the dollar figures tossed around, but then acknowledges that its the right move. “The figures are absolutely staggering.” … “We will resist the temptation here to trace Contreras’s disappointing career with the Yankees and wonder if that fate could find Matsuzaka.” … “[T]he urgency is back on Yawkey Way and this can only be a good thing … “
*“That would send the Dice Man (D-Mat? We badly need a nickname for this guy) …” Why? Because Dan finds it hard to pronounce anything more complicated than Whitey MacPaddy.
His failing memory:
*“The 2006 Red Sox suffered an unspeakable spate of injuries, but their dysfunctional roster was woefully equipped for land mines encountered in the second half of the season.” Let’s recall what Shaughnessy wrote on April 3, 2006: “[T]hese 2006 Red Sox are a new-look team, stressing defense, pitching, and boredom … the Idiot culture is gone and has been replaced by an organizational professionalism that would make Boss Steinbrenner proud.
*On that same day, he also predicted the Sox would win the AL East: “[M]any experts … dismiss the Red Sox as a noncontender and perhaps a third-place team in the vaunted American League East. … That opinion is not shared here. … It says here this is the year the Red Sox finally vault over the Yankees and win the AL East outright for the first time since 1995 (ah, the Kevin Kennedy years).” Dan, get thee to a neurogolist.
“Boston’s sad, sloppy September was little more than extended spring training (at whopping big league prices).” Right, like the Boston Globe cuts subscription prices every time they have a layoff.
Tuck this away. The CHB writes, “A Red Sox starting rotation of Matsuzaka, Jonathan Papelbon, Josh Beckett, Curt Schilling, and Tim Wakefield looks pretty good.” Let’s remember this when, in the midst of a three-game losing streak in June, The CHB spends a good 40 inches of column space bitching about how the Sox management should have known better than to bet the season on a rotation made up primarily of guys who had either never started in the majors or are old enough to be dead.
And a quick farewell. It’s nonsense like this that a little more than a year ago spurred me to launch this column. All good things end, however, and this is one. I am officially retiring this site. Thanks to everyone who read and commented, especially Jenny, who carried this place for the past several months.
Maybe we’ll get lucky and Dan will realize it’s time for him to go too.
Hey, we can wish, right?
(btw–CHB is courtesy of Carl Everett who dubbed him “curly haired boyfriend”.)